Science Editor and Publisher

Advanced search

Publication language and the journal scientometric indicators in global citation databases

Full Text:


This article continues the topic of preparing and developing scholarly journals, which aim to reach the international level. A particular focus of the article is how journals can increase their impact in terms of citation indicators calculated by Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus. Aim. To investigate a relationship between WoS and Scopus scientometric indicators, the language of publications and the amount of English-language materials published in journals. Methods. An analysis of scholarly journals published in 23 countries was conducted using the Ulrich’s database. Their scientometric indicators were assessed using the data derived from Scopus. Results. The obtained results demonstrate a number of specific regularities. It is found, on the one hand, that the larger the country and the more journals it publishes, the fewer its journals publish the full text of their articles in English. On the other hand, the smaller the country and the fewer journals it publishes, the greater the proportion of journals that publish their content entirely in English. These results manifest the desire of larger countries to maintain their national language as the language of science, while smaller non-English speaking countries aim to achieve the international recognition by presenting the country’s scientific achievements in English. However, according to the analysed indicators, journals publishing their content in English are read and cited better. Those journals that publish their content entirely in the country’s national language show significantly lower levels of citation. The same trend is observed for both bilingual journals (those publishing articles either in the national or English languages or having a small number of English articles along with publications in the national language) and multilingual journals. Translated journals published by Pleiades or Springer and journals having two parallel versions (one in the national language and another in English) demonstrate approximately the same level of citation. Conclusion. Journals published in parallel versions are shown to perform better in terms of citation, largely because they cover both the national and English-speaking readership. Moreover, the use of certain technological tools permits the citations of both versions to be merged. A considerable attention is paid to the discussion of the RF state science policy with respect to measuring national scientific results and various ethical issues arising in this context.



About the Author

O. V. Kirillova
Association of Science Editors and Publishers (ASEP)
Russian Federation
Cand. Sci. (Eng.), President


1. Кириллова О. В. Как оформить статью и научный журнал в целом для корректного индексирования в международных наукометрических базах данных. Научный редактор и издатель. 2018;3(1-2):52–72. DOI: 10.24069/2542-0267-2018-1-2-52-72

2. Фетисова Н. Наука в изоляции. Атомный эксперт. 2019;(4). Режим доступа: science_isolation

3. Дубов А. Китай впервые обогнал США по количеству научных публикаций. N+1. 20 янв. 2018. Режим доступа:

4. Science and Engineering Indicators 2018. NSF National Science Board. Available at: statistics/2018/nsb20181/assets/nsb20181.pdf

5. An Introduction to Citation Stacking. Enago Academy. Available at:

6. Heneberg P. From Excessive Journal Self-Cites to Citation Stacking: Analysis of Journal Self-Citation Kinetics in Search for Journals, Which Boost Their Scientometric Indicators. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(4):e0153730. DOI: 10.1371/ journal. pone.0153730

7. Steiginga S. The Scopus solution to predatory journals.Predatory journals and publishing. Re-evaluation. [Презентация]. Cеминар: «Рекомендации экспертов CSAB Scopus и главных редакторов издательства Elsevier для редакторов и издателей России и стран СНГ», 17 апреля, 2017 г. Режим доступа: materials/28-Sem0417/170417_0930_Steiginga.pdf.

8. Кун А. Публикуйся, и кто должен погибнуть: ты или наука? Научный редактор и издатель. 2019;4(1–2):00–00. DOI: 10.24069/2542-0267-2019-1-2-00-00

9. Лазарев В. С. Власть библиометрических иллюзий над ленивыми, профанация плодотворных идей и проклятье «парабиблиометрической» оценки науки. Научный редактор и издатель. 2019;4(1–2):00–00. DOI: 10.24069/2542-0267-2019-1-2-00-00

10. Criteria for the evaluation of research units: the HCERES standards. Paris: High Council for the Evaluation of Research and High Education; 2014. 32 p.

11. Hvistendahl M. China pursues fraudsters in science publishing. Science. Nov. 20, 2015. DOI: 10.1126/science. aad7471

12. Jia H. Retractions pulling China back. Call for tougher sanctions in response to growth in papers recalled for misconduct. Nature Index, 17 Nov. 2017. Available at:

13. Hu G., Yang Y., Tang L. Retraction and Research Integrity Education in China. Science and Engineering Ethics. 2019;25:325. DOI: 10.1007/s11948-017-0017-x

14. Ever heard of China’s “five don’ts of academic publishing?” Available at: https://retractionwatch. com/2016/10/20/ever-heard-of-chinas-five-donts-of-academic-publishing/

15. Фокус-Scopus. Как за деньги купить место среди соавторов западного научного журнала. Режим доступа: cF73YJBZN6Ys

16. Exclusive: Russian site says it has brokered authorships for more than 10,000 researchers. Available at:

17. Russian website offers authorship for a fee in papers accepted for publication. Available at: insights/russian-website-offers-authorship-for-a-fee-in-papers-accepted-for-publication?utm_source=newsletter&utm_ medium=email&utm_campaign=insights_03082019_heading_template1&_hsenc=p2ANqtz--ehoPffW_uDumH0yrL30xZ RvOrIZ8CQeIis0iX0yseMJaJUDCjMp1D8SmQr-Kgi4lpJsrMaVifqQs4j33DvjZi0A8EZg&_hsmi=75307863

18. Рю Д. Роль английского языка в международном издательском деле. Научный редактор и издатель. 2017;2(1):14-18. DOI: 10.24069/2542-0267-2017-1-14-18

For citation:

Kirillova O.V. Publication language and the journal scientometric indicators in global citation databases. Science Editor and Publisher. 2019;4(1-2):21-33. (In Russ.)

Views: 1349

ISSN 2542-0267 (Print)
ISSN 2541-8122 (Online)